68 replies to this topic

[clana33]

I guess everyone liked the 2nd movie the best. I agree with them. It had a good plot and the Cindy-Timmy-Jimmy love-triangle thing rocked! :kawaii:

[the sapphire rose]

I personally liked the second one. It was funny seeing Jimmy and Timmy fighting over Cindy. This is one of the first eppisodes I saw where Jimmy actually admitted he liked Cindy. :wub: I just thought it was cute. The third one and first one are great too but this one is my favorite! ^_^

[ultraerica]

yeah, the second one was probably the best, in my eyes. the first one was okay, and the second one was very disappointing. i waited so long for it to air and when it did, i was not at all satisfied with it. *sighs* oh well, there's nothing i can do about it...... -_-

[John Richards]

Bumping for a variety of odd, assorted opinions.
First off, I wanted to say that I think I may be Neko's somewhat reverse... Now, I would call myself a JB shipper with 60 to 70% approval for JC, and really not being able to stand JA.
Now, getting back to the main subject-
I like JTPH2 best. Certainly, it's full of JC, which I think is okay. But I would hate it if not for one thing- the antifairies getting sucked into the hypercube scene. I'm not even a FOP fan and I loved it.
I like JTPH3 worst. It's okay in the funny department, but everyone was way too far out of character. Furthermore, the fact that the main villain spent most (nearly all) of his time in 2 or 2.5 dimensions bugged me. Also, I think that the 2.5 dimensions was really more like 2.25 dimensions. It seemed more like FOP animation than JN animation. Additionally, dumb Jimmy was funny for about an episode in Normal Boy, but didn't really work in this episode. Actually, come to think of it, the reason Dumb Jimmy works worse than Magicless Timmy is that Magicless Timmy still has his character intact, while Dumb Jimmy, in becoming weak, also loses his personality. Arguably, the comparison between Sheen and Cosmo in JTPH2 is lesser than the unspoken comparison between Dumb Jimmy and Cosmo. With Cosmo magicless, Dumb Jimmy is effectively just a second Cosmo.
JTPH was pretty good. I hardly ever watch FOP, but I actually liked the scenes in Dimmsdale and Fairy World better than the scenes in Retroville.
Also, I must say that I laughed when Neko mentioned Cindy/Timmy being incompatible. They're almost physically incompatible in Neutron At War, which may become more important later. Reread chapter one for hints.

[John Richards]

Oh, also, my opinion on number one...

Oddly enough, I think that number one was biased MORE towards JN and LESS towards FOP. As in, it was primarily JN. Here's my reasoning:
Jimmy solved a problem in Timmy's world, without any of the JN auxilary characters. Timmy solved a problem in Jimmy's world, without any of the FOP auxilary characters. Timmy's skills depend on auxilary characters (Cosmo and Wanda). This means that naturally, Jimmy got more of his natural pwnage than Timmy did.

[JimmyxxCindy4EVER]

Ya make some EXCELLENT points, John. I agree; dumb Jimmy in JTPH3 was just an alter-ego of Cosmo. It would've been better if they kept his personality without the smarts, instead of the way they put him, WITHOUT smarts OR personality. I think that the first one was the best, mostly cuz I've only seen the 2nd one only once or twice. Although I do agree that the FOP animators could've put a LITTLE effort into making Timmy look like he fit into Jimmy's world! However, they did an EXCELLENT job transforming Jimmy into 2-dimensional form, or was that the JN animators that did that?? I dunno...

[~Baby Broadway~]

I have seen none of them!!!!!! :'( :'( :'(

[JimmyxxCindy4EVER]

Here's a pic I made based on the JTPH2:


Hahaha, they look real determined to claim Cindy, don't they?! XD I crack up whenever I look at this one!!

[gabBy-gabBz^^]

Here's a pic I made based on the JTPH2:


Hahaha, they look real determined to claim Cindy, don't they?! XD I crack up whenever I look at this one!!

LOL! I love it!!! They're claiming Cindy! How did ya make it?!?

[CjIiNmDmYy]

I voted JTPH2 because it was so funny cuz Timmy and Jimmy both wanted to take Cindy to the dance. And the way she was dancing between both universes was whacky and a bit wierd!

[Urvy]

JTPH 3 somehow reminded me of the Paper Mario games, I expected Mario to pop in any minute!

[Katy]

the first onme was my fave. i didn't like the j/c/t love triangle in jtph2. I can't see jimmy competing for cindy, and ican't see him calling himself a lover at his age, but maybe when he's older. Also, I couldn't stand jimmy and timmy sharing cindy. Also, timmy marries either trixie or tootie, which means that cindy and timmy don't end up being together.
I don't know if jimmy marries cindy in the good future. The non- evil libby future didn't give enough clues to who jimmy married so who knows who he marries in the future. I laso was disappointed with jtph3 since I thought that juimmy and timmy making a villian was lame, and why would the heck they's name that robot shirley.

[CjIiNmDmYy]

I also really don't get why they name the villain Shirley and you're right about Jimmy and Timmy sharing Cindy thing. It's was just...UGH!!!

[Katy]

jimmy was acting out of charcter in 2 & 3. Jimmy in the show tried denying any feelings for any girlincluding betty in front of people, so i can't see him competeing for cindy and calling hinself a lover.

[JimmyxxCindy4EVER]

LOL! I love it!!! They're claiming Cindy! How did ya make it?!?

I just used the Paint program commonly found on all Windows computers. It took a while, but it was REALLY easy for me, cuz I'm naturally artistic.

[CjIiNmDmYy]

jimmy was acting out of charcter in 2 & 3. Jimmy in the show tried denying any feelings for any girlincluding betty in front of people, so i can't see him competeing for cindy and calling hinself a lover.

Yes, you're so right!

[Katy]

i wonder who's idea was that to make jimmy and timmy compete for cindy

[CjIiNmDmYy]

Maybe it was Kieth's or someone else...

[Katy]

all i know is that idea was lame, and i;'ll pound the guy who thought of that idea. just kidding

[CjIiNmDmYy]

Yeah, coz Cindy belongs with Jimmy and Trixie with Timmy.